What language
functions can be reported?
Recent studies have
shown how reported speech can work in interaction, giving participants a way of
dealing with possible tensions and signalling intended frames. This paper
proposes a taxonomy of functions for direct reports of speech (and of writing
and thought) in focus group discussions. Reported speech always suggests a
shift in frame, and that shift can focus attention on the setting factuality,
speaker's position, or the words themselves (or on several of these aspects at
once). Reported speech both depicts the experience of the original utterance,
and detaches the reported utterance from the reporting speaker; so within each
of these categories, reported speech can have a range of functions from an
emphasis on direct experience to an emphasis on detachment. Focus groups differ
from some comparable group discussions in several ways, but they can serve as a
guide to the ways participants in other kinds of group discussions might use
reported speech to orient to other members of the group and to the purpose of
the discussion.
Direct Speech
|
→
|
Reported Speech
|
→
|
||
"I work in
Argentina"
|
|
He said that he worked in
Argentina
|
"I am doing my job"
|
|
He said that he was doing his job
|
→
|
||
"We saw a good film on TV"
|
|
He said they had seen a good film on TV.
|
"I was dancing with Mary"
|
|
He said he had been dancing with Mary
|
→
|
||
"I have done this before"
|
|
She said that
she had done that before
|
"I have been doing this for two years"
|
|
He said that he had been doing that for two years
|
→
|
||
"I will visit my mother"
|
|
He said that he would visit his mother
|
"I will be flying to Spain"
|
|
He said that he would be flying to Spain
|
→
|
||
"I will have arrived there by 5 pm"
|
|
He said he
would have arrived here by 5 pm
|
"I will have been
selling books for
two years"
|
|
He said that he would have been
sellingbooks for two years
|
What /which reporting
verbs do we use to those funtions?
Function
and strength
|
Example
verbs
|
NEUTRAL: verbs used to say what the
writer describes in factual terms, demonstrates, refers to, and discusses,
and verbs used to explain his/her methodology.
|
describe, show, reveal, study, demonstate, note, point out, indicate,
report, observe, assume, take into consideration, examine, go on to say that,
state, believe (unless this is a strong belief), mention, etc.
|
TENTATIVE: verbs used to say what the
writer suggests or speculates on (without being absolutely certain).
|
suggest,
speculate, intimate, hypothesise, moot, imply, propose, recommend, posit the
view that, question the view that, postulate, etc.
|
STRONG: verbs used to say what the
writer makes strong arguments and claims for.
|
argue, claim, emphasise, contend, maintain, assert, theorize, support
the view that, deny, negate, refute, reject, challenge, strongly believe
that, counter the view/argument that, etc.
|
|
No hay comentarios.:
Publicar un comentario